Skip to main content
Back to blog
Restaurants 26 Oct 2026 8 min read

Best Mexican Restaurants in Sheffield, Ranked by Google Rating

Sheffield's Mexican restaurants ranked by Google rating and number of reviews, from the city centre to Heeley and Neepsend, with the method spelled out.

Edmond BojalilEB

Edmond Bojalil

Recetas Mexas

Best Mexican Restaurants in Sheffield, Ranked by Google Rating

This is our answer to the search for the best Mexican restaurants in Sheffield, and it rests on a rule you can check rather than on our taste. We took every Mexican venue in our Sheffield listings, kept those with at least fifty Google reviews, and ordered them by average Google rating, using the number of reviews to break ties. The figures are those our directory held in October 2026. 5 venues pass that bar, out of 9 Mexican venues we list in the city.

We have not eaten our way round the city to score these kitchens, and nothing on this page is a tasting verdict. A Google average is a crowd measure, which makes it honest in one way and blunt in another. We explain its blind spots further down, and we list every venue that did not make the table, so you can see exactly what the rule leaves out.

The ranking

Names link to each venue's page in our directory, with address, listed hours and website where we hold one.

#VenueAddressGoogle ratingReviews
1The Street Food Chef90 Arundel St, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 4RE4.71,669
2Fuego 1987: Cutlery Works73 Neepsend Ln, Neepsend, Sheffield S3 8AT4.3156
3Amigos617 London Rd, Heeley, Sheffield S2 4HT4.21,208
4EL Chappo11 Backfields, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 4HJ3.8189
5Taco Mex Abbeydale road,995 Abbeydale Rd, Sheffield S7 2QD3.455

Unlike the tight tables we see in some cities, Sheffield's ranking has real spread: the gap between the top of the table and the bottom is wide. That makes the order more meaningful than usual. It also makes the review column worth a look, because the largest review counts in this table dwarf the smallest, and an average built on that many reviews barely moves from month to month.

The venues at the top

Hours come from each venue's directory listing. Match days at Bramall Lane and Hillsborough, and term time at the two universities, change how busy the city centre is, so check before you go.

The Street Food Chef

Address: 90 Arundel St, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 4RE
Google rating: 4.7 from 1,669 reviews (as held in our directory, October 2026)
Opening hours (directory listing): Mon–Fri 11:00–22:00 · Sat 10:00–22:00 · Sun 10:00–21:00
Website: streetfoodchef.co.uk

On Arundel Street in the city centre, between the station and the Moor. It leads the table on rating and has the largest number of reviews in the city, which is the strongest combination a crowd ranking can produce: a high average that is also very stable. The name says what it is: a street-food kitchen rather than a sit-down restaurant.

Fuego 1987: Cutlery Works

Address: 73 Neepsend Ln, Neepsend, Sheffield S3 8AT
Google rating: 4.3 from 156 reviews (as held in our directory, October 2026)
Opening hours (directory listing): Mon–Thu 11:00–21:00 · Fri–Sat 11:00–22:00 · Sun 11:00–21:00

In Neepsend, the former industrial district north of the centre, inside the Cutlery Works building on Neepsend Lane. Its review pool is far smaller than the venue above, so its average is a less settled number, but second place in a table with this much spread is a clear result.

Amigos

Address: 617 London Rd, Heeley, Sheffield S2 4HT
Google rating: 4.2 from 1,208 reviews (as held in our directory, October 2026)
Opening hours (directory listing): Mon closed · Tue–Fri 17:00–22:00 · Sat–Sun 13:00–22:00
Website: amigossheffield.co.uk

On London Road in Heeley, south of the centre, a restaurant rather than a counter. Its listing describes a split-level dining room serving traditional Mexican dishes and grills. Its review count is close to the leader's, so its average is just as steady, only a little lower.

The rest of the ranked venues

The other two ranked venues are EL Chappo on Backfields in the city centre and Taco Mex Abbeydale road, on Abbeydale Road. Their averages are lower: 3.8 on Google from 189 reviews and 3.4 on Google from 55 reviews respectively. A lower Google average often reflects service, waiting times or delivery problems as much as the food, so read the recent reviews before you write a venue off; but the rule is the rule, and they sit at the bottom of the table.

Below the threshold

These Sheffield venues are in our directory but not in the ranking, because our directory does not hold a Google rating for them yet. One of them, on Dyson Place in Sharrow Vale, is described in its listing as a modern Mexican restaurant that has won awards; its absence from the table is a gap in our data, not a verdict.

  • Barburrito Sheffield, Unit 63, Meadowhall Centre, Sheffield S9 1EP (no Google rating in our directory)
  • El Paso, 10 Cumberland Street, Sheffield S1 4PT (no Google rating in our directory)
  • Las Iguanas Sheffield, Unit 59, Level 2, Meadowhall Centre, Sheffield S9 1EP (no Google rating in our directory)
  • Pellizco, 8 Dyson Place, Sharrow, Sheffield S11 8XX (no Google rating in our directory)

Two of these are chain branches in the Oasis dining area of the Meadowhall shopping centre. One city-centre venue on Cumberland Street describes itself as Mexican and Italian; we list it, but it is not a specialist Mexican kitchen, and the same goes for the Latin American grill chain at Meadowhall. Our guide to Tex-Mex and fusion in the UK explains how we tell these apart.

Sheffield by area

  • City centre. Arundel Street, Backfields and Cumberland Street, a short walk from the station and the Moor. This is where the top-ranked venue is, and where most visitors will eat.
  • Neepsend and Kelham Island. The converted works north of the centre now hold bars and food halls; one ranked venue is here.
  • The south-west. London Road, Abbeydale Road and Sharrow Vale run through the residential districts south of the centre, with a ranked restaurant, a takeaway and the unranked venue on Dyson Place.
  • Meadowhall. Chain branches for shoppers, out by the M1.

For a shorter list of places, see where to eat Mexican in Sheffield, and for the wider region, our regional guide to Mexican food outside London.

Reading a Google rating

An average tells you how satisfied reviewers were. It does not measure how closely a kitchen follows any regional tradition. In Sheffield a few patterns are worth keeping in mind:

  • Volume steadies a score. Two of the ranked venues have far more reviews than the rest. Their averages are very reliable; the smaller venues' averages are less so.
  • Students review in bursts. A large student population means surges of reviews in term time, many from first visits.
  • Counters and restaurants are judged differently. A quick counter is rated on speed and value, a sit-down restaurant on the whole evening. Compare like with like.
  • Tex-Mex is a separate tradition. Fajitas, nachos and chilli con carne grew up in Texas; they are a cuisine in their own right, not a failed attempt at Mexican food, but they are not what a taquería in Mexico City serves.

What to order

UNESCO's 2010 inscription of traditional Mexican cuisine as intangible cultural heritage puts maize, beans and chilli at the base of the whole tradition, with nixtamalisation, cooking maize with lime before grinding it, as a defining technique. The taco, a folded corn tortilla with a filling, is the everyday form of that tradition, and the tortilla is the first thing to judge.

  • Tacos on corn tortillas. If a menu offers both corn and flour, try corn first. To cook a classic at home, our carnitas tacos recipe is a good start.
  • A slow-cooked filling. Braises such as tinga travel well and show off a kitchen's chillies; our chicken tinga recipe explains the chipotle base.
  • The salsas. Ask what is fresh that day. Our pico de gallo is the simplest place to start at home.

Frequently asked questions

How was the ranking decided?

By average Google rating as held in our directory in October 2026, among Sheffield venues with at least fifty reviews, with the number of reviews breaking ties.

Why is the restaurant in Sharrow Vale not ranked?

Our directory does not hold a Google rating for it yet. It is listed in the section below the threshold and in our restaurant directory.

Are the Meadowhall chain branches included?

They are listed, but without Google figures in our directory they cannot be ranked.

Where can I buy Mexican ingredients in Sheffield?

Our shop directory lists the grocers we have mapped in South Yorkshire and the online Mexican specialists that deliver nationwide.

Sources

  • UNESCO, Traditional Mexican cuisine: ancestral, ongoing community culture, the Michoacán paradigm (inscribed 2010): ich.unesco.org
  • Wikipedia, Taco (history and regional varieties): en.wikipedia.org
  • Wikipedia, Tex-Mex cuisine: en.wikipedia.org
Edmond Bojalil
Edmond Bojalil

Founder, Recetas Mexas

Mexican from Puebla, IT professional and foodie. Author of 1000+ authentic Mexican recipes adapted for home kitchens worldwide. Based in Madrid since 2018.

Read more