Skip to main content
Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie)
DessertsEasyFree

Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie)

Made it? Rate it
35 min (20 prep + 15 cook) Easy 8 servings Guanajuato
Edmond Bojalil
Edmond Bojalil

Recetas Mexas

Published: 24 Mar 2026 · Updated: 14 Nov 2026
Share:
Mexican goat milk caramel tart in a biscuit base with chopped walnuts.

About this Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie) recipe

Mexican cajeta (goat milk caramel) tart in a biscuit base with chopped walnuts. A Guanajuato dessert with intense caramel flavour and aroma of caramelised goat's milk.

History and origin of Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie)

Cajeta is one of Mexico's most iconic sweets and the culinary heart of the state of Guanajuato. Its name comes from the little wooden boxes in which it was traditionally sold at markets. It is made from goat's milk (though cow's milk and mixed versions also exist) cooked slowly with sugar until the Maillard reaction turns the mixture into a thick, dark caramel of incomparable flavour, more complex and deeper than ordinary dulce de leche. Pay de cajeta is a modern adaptation of the traditional sweet to the Western tart format. This fusion perfectly reflects the way contemporary Mexican baking takes pre-Hispanic and colonial ingredients and flavours and presents them in formats that respect tradition while making them easier to eat and to make at home. Celaya, a city in Guanajuato, is considered the world capital of cajeta and the sweets made from it. Its shops and markets offer dozens of varieties: vanilla, cinnamon, guava, wine-laced and burnt cajeta. Pay de cajeta carries that flavour into a dessert with a modern presentation, and today it can be found in patisseries, cafés and restaurants throughout the country.

Estimated cost

£8.69

Total cost

£1.09

Per serving

* Approximate prices based on UK supermarkets

Nutritional information per serving

420

Calories

7g

Protein

48g

Carbohydrates

24g

Fat

1g

Fibre

280mg

Sodium

* Approximate values. May vary depending on ingredients used.

How to make Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie)

  1. 1

    Crush 200g biscuits (Marie or digestive) in a food processor. Mix with 80g melted butter until it resembles damp sand.

    Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie) – Step 1: Crush 200g biscuits (Marie or digestive) in a

    💡 You can also crush the biscuits in a bag with a rolling pin.

  2. 2

    Press the biscuit mixture into a 22cm tart tin, pressing up the sides too. Bake 10 minutes at 180°C. Leave to cool.

    Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie) – Step 2: Press the biscuit mixture into a 22cm tart
  3. 3

    In a bowl, beat 200g cream cheese at room temperature until smooth. Add 400g cajeta and 1 teaspoon vanilla extract. Mix until combined.

    Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie) – Step 3: In a bowl, beat 200g cream cheese at

    💡 Mexican goat milk cajeta is the authentic choice; if unavailable, use Argentinian dulce de leche.

  4. 4

    Pour the cajeta mixture over the cooled biscuit base. Spread evenly.

    Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie) – Step 4: Pour the cajeta mixture over the cooled biscuit
  5. 5

    Scatter 100g chopped walnuts over the surface. Refrigerate at least 3 hours, preferably overnight.

    Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie) – Step 5: Scatter 100g chopped walnuts over the surface

    💡 The cold sets the filling texture.

  6. 6

    Warm 2 tablespoons extra cajeta (on top of the 400 g in the filling) and drizzle over the tart before serving. Cut with a warm knife and serve cold.

    Pay de Cajeta (Mexican Goat Milk Caramel Pie) – Step 6: Warm 2 tablespoons extra cajeta (on top of

How did it turn out? Rate it

Rate it with one tap. No account needed.

or write a full review

Rate this recipe

Edmond Bojalil
Edmond Bojalil

Founder, Recetas Mexas

Mexican from Puebla, IT professional and foodie. Author of 1000+ authentic Mexican recipes adapted for home kitchens worldwide. Based in Madrid since 2018.

Read more

Related Recipes

Related Guides

Learn more about these ingredients and dishes

Enjoyed this?

Follow on TikTok for Mexican recipe & restaurant videos, and get updates by email.

Follow on TikTok